top of page

Sometimes, the biggest opportunities come from looking beyond the brief

Writer: Andrew Burton
Andrew Burton
Nov 4
5 min read

One of the things I've learnt from over 30 years working in retail and catering and 7 years in consultancy, is that the reason we're asked to visit a garden centre isn't always where the biggest opportunity lies.

I might have been invited to look at a farm shop design, review a restaurant layout or spend time understanding benchmark sales. I always arrive with a clear brief and a particular job to do, but as I walk the site, talk to the people running the business and observe how everything works together, something else catches my attention. Perhaps it's a department that isn't performing as well as it could or something that's the wrong size or in the wrong place; maybe the way customers move around the building is restricting sales; or the proposed idea could create operational problems that nobody has fully considered.  These moments are interesting because they remind me that a garden centre is never simply a collection of individual departments or buildings.  It's a connected business, where decisions in one area can have a considerable effect somewhere else.


Over the years, I've seen just how much difference it can make when you recognise those connections.


Looking beyond the project brief


On one occasion, I visited a garden centre with the brief to look at its farm shop design.  That was the specific reason for the visit, and naturally, that was where my attention was initially focused.


However, spending time looking at the wider business highlighted a different opportunity, not in the farm shop, but within the restaurant.  The restaurant was not performing to its full potential, and it became clear that there was scope to do more with the catering operation.  That led to a different conversation and, ultimately, we worked to address this opportunity before any work was started on the retail areas. 


As a result, the restaurant has since grown its turnover by 130% and development of the retail areas that we initially went to view, are now underway.


For me, this illustrates an important point. Had we concentrated exclusively on the farm shop, we might have completed the original job perfectly well, but missed an opportunity to make a much bigger contribution to the business.


When the restaurant leads you back into retail


I've experienced the reverse situation, too.  On another visit, I was asked to look at a garden centre's restaurant design.  As we considered the space, it became apparent that the opportunity extended beyond the restaurant itself.  The wider retail layout and the way customers moved through the shop needed to be considered as part of the same conversation.  By reviewing the overall layout and changing the customer flow into the restaurant, we were able to improve the relationship between the retail and catering areas. 


One of the results has been a doubling of giftware turnover since the restaurant opened.


This demonstrates how interconnected retail and catering really are.  A restaurant isn't simply somewhere customers go to eat, separate from the rest of the business. Its position, the journey customers take to reach it and what they encounter along the way can all influence their shopping experience.  Sometimes, improving one part of a garden centre means rethinking another. This is why we always look at the bigger picture, not just the component parts.


The value of asking a different question


Another example came from a review of benchmark sales for a garden centre.  The initial task was to understand how the business was performing commercially, but looking at the numbers, alongside the layout, raised a more fundamental question about the proposed development.  The garden centre business in question were planning to build a new structure in a location that we felt would negatively affect processes, productivity and potentially turnover.  It would have been easy to look at the proposal as a straightforward building project. Instead, we stepped back and considered how the whole site operated, including how staff managed stock, how work moved through the business and how the available retail space was being used.


By rethinking the layout and repositioning areas of the garden centre, we identified opportunities to improve processes, including stock management, while freeing up valuable, high-footfall retail space to support turnover.


The important thing here wasn't simply finding a better location for a structure. It was recognising that the original proposal needed to be considered in the context of the entire business.


Sometimes, the best investment isn't about creating more space. It's about making the space you already have work harder.


Experience gives you a different perspective


What connects these three examples is that none of the resulting opportunities were the original reason for the visit.  They emerged from looking beyond the immediate task and understanding how the different parts of the business influenced one another.


I think experience plays a significant role in this.  After working with many different garden centres, you begin to recognise patterns. You see how certain layouts affect customer behaviour, how operational decisions influence productivity and how retail and catering can support one another commercially.  You also learn to question things that might otherwise be taken for granted.


That doesn't mean assuming that you know the answers before you've understood the business.  Quite the opposite.  Every garden centre has its own character, customers, challenges and ambitions.  What works in one location may be entirely wrong for another.  Instead, the value of experience is being able to draw on what you've seen elsewhere, recognise where there might be an opportunity and then work with the people who know their business best to find the right solution.


And that last point matters. Garden centre owners and their teams know their customers, their people and the realities of running the operation every day. Our role is to bring a different perspective, ask the questions that might not otherwise be asked and help turn opportunities into practical improvements.


Looking at the whole business


I believe some of the most valuable work we do at Pleydell Smithyman happens when we look beyond the original brief.  It might mean identifying a way to grow sales in a department that wasn't even part of the conversation. It might mean improving the connection between retail and catering, or recognising that a proposed development could create problems rather than solve them.


The results can be significant: stronger turnover, better use of space, more efficient processes and a better experience for customers and staff.

Of course, not every observation will lead to a major project, and not every opportunity will be right for every business.  But being prepared to look, question and explore is often where meaningful improvements begin.


When I visit a garden centre, I want to understand not just what it is that I am there to do, but how the business works as a whole and what it's trying to achieve. 


Because sometimes, the most valuable contribution we can make isn't answering the question we were originally asked.  It's recognising that there's another question worth asking. And that this might just be where the biggest opportunity lies.

 
 

PROUDLY ASSOCIATED WITH:

farm retail association logo

FARM RETAIL 

ASSOCIATION

GCA Garden Centre Association Logo

GARDEN CENTRE 

ASSOCIATION

National Farm Attractions Network Logo

NATIONAL FARM 

ATTRACTIONS NETWORK

Horticultural Trade Association HTA Logo

HORTICULTURAL TRADES ASSOCIATION

Landscape Institute Logo

LANDSCAPE

INSTITUTE

CLA logo

COUNTRY LAND & BUSINESS ASSOCIATION

©PleydellSmithyman
bottom of page